Healthcare Finance NewsHealthcare Finance News
  • Home
  • Sections
    • Industry News
    • Community Care
    • Hospitals & IDNs
    • Payers
    • Solutions and Services
  • Issues
    • March 2010
    • Jan/Feb 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • Sept. 2009
  • Resource Central
    • All Resources
    • Research
    • White Papers
    • Web Seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Newsletters
  • RSS
  • Twitter feed
  • LinkedIn group
Select Your Homepage
Search eConnect
Login | Register
Home » Blogs » Industry News

E-mail to a FriendPrint
Social Bookmarking
  • Delicious Delicious
  • Digg Digg
  • StumbleUpon StumbleUpon
  • Reddit Reddit
  • Newsvine Newsvine
  • Furl Furl
  • Facebook Facebook
  • Google Google
  • Yahoo Yahoo
The end of the "robust" public option and the potential for "robust" cost containment?

The end of the "robust" public option and the potential for "robust" cost containment?

November 13, 2009 | Robert Laszewski

Suggested Content

  • Senate votes to delay doc pay cut until Oct. 1
  • Blog: Health Reform Could Harm Medicaid Patients
  • Premier offers Congress its ideas for healthcare reform
  • House delays physician pay cut until March 1
  • Health reform hangs in the balance

Two things happened this week that in tandem have the potential to lead to a compromise over a healthcare bill.

First, there are unconfirmed reports that Senate Majority Leader Reid is leaning toward offering the neutered version of the public option like that in the House--not tied to Medicare rates, providers not required to participate, and provider reimbursement rates negotiated.

The second development is the growing call for a bipartisan commission to offer solutions to entitlement spending (Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security) that the Congress would have to vote up or down via a super majority vote.

No healthcare bill will pass either the House or the Senate with a robust Medicare-like public option--as I have been telling you since spring. But this neutered variety, which the CBO said would likely develop rates higher than in the commercial market, has passed the House (by a very slim margin) and could potentially pass in the Senate. That is by no means certain with at least a couple of the Senators Reid needs to get to 60 votes indicating they wouldn't support most if not all versions of a public option.

The other growing discomfort with the current healthcare bills--particularly among the Democratic moderates and conservatives Reid and Pelosi need on their side--is the lack of any cost containment in the bills. That anxiety probably has more potential to derail a healthcare bill than anything else.

But now at least 15 Democratic Senators are saying they will not vote to increase the federal debt ceiling without an entitlement commission.

With the Congress facing the need to vote an increase in the federal debt ceiling by mid-December, we could see such a commission enacted before any final vote on healthcare.

I will suggest that if we had that entitlement commission in place many Democrats would be far more comfortable voting for a healthcare bill. While I doubt many Republicans would be enthusiastic about the healthcare bill itself, they would feel a lot better if there were such a commission.

Of course, all of this depends upon just how robust that entitlement commission would really be. There are few if any details now on the table. It would also depend upon the final details in any public option--there are still fears even the more neutered variety could have unfair market advantages or later be converted to the more powerful model.

Would such a commission be more focused on tax increases to narrow the entitlement programs' impact on the deficit? How much power would it have to implement systemic health system change? Would it end up being a one-time effort or more focused on the likely need for ongoing systemic change as it became clear what was working and what was not?

And so far Pelosi and her powerful House committee chairs have been more than just unenthusiastic about the ceding a huge part of the federal budget to an independent entitlement commission (not to mention losing a source of lots of campaign contributions).

In the end, a healthcare bill might just hinge more not on how "robust" the public option would be but on how "robust" an entitlement commission would be.

Robert Laszewski blogs regularly at Health Care Policy and Marketplace Review.

Related Topics:
  • Congress
  • Medicare
  • Senate

Reader Comments (0)Login to Post a Comment

receive news by email

Most Popular

Latest Headlines
Most Popular
  • Analysis: Medical malpractice payments continue to fall
  • Recession hurts, but pharmacists are still in demand
  • Online auction nets Maryland health system $1.25M in energy savings
  • Healthcare employment rose in February
  • Sebelius calls on insurance company executives to justify premium hikes
  • Operating improvements drive debt rating boost for Connecticut hospital
  • Michigan doctor convicted in $18.3M Medicare fraud scheme
  • Puerto Rican coalition asks Congress for health equality
  • Creative payment reform initiatives abound nationwide
  • Senate votes to delay doc pay cut until Oct. 1
Syndicate content

HEALTHCARE FINANCE JOB SPOT

  • Healthcare Consulting Partner/Leader Performance Improvement, Healthcare Finance and Operations - Tatum - Chicago and Dallas
  • Vice President of Medical Services - Wheeler Clinic - Plainville, CT
  • Medical Chart Review Auditor - Connolly Healthcare - Philadelphia, PA
  • Senior Financial Auditor - Parkland Health & Hospital System - Dallas, TX
  • Senior Financial Auditor - Parkland Health & Hospital System - Dallas, Texas
more jobs
  • EHRWatch.com

    EHRWatch.com offers news, commentary and community participation on the developments in electronic health records.

  • Priming the Pump

    Priming the Pump provides practical news on the stimulus package and the incentives that it offers to healthcare providers.

  • NHINWatch

    Visit NHINWatch.com for coverage of the Nationwide Health Information Network.

  • Mobile Health Watch

    Stay up to date on the latest mobility news at Mobile Health Watch.

  • MedTech Publishing

    Visit our company Web page to learn more about MedTech Publishing.

  • LinkedIn

    Join our LinkedIn group to connect with other Healthcare Finance News readers.

  • Healthcare Finance Job Spot

    Check out the latest open positions at Healthcare Finance Job Spot.

  • Healthcare IT News

    Visit Healthcare IT News for the latest health information technology news.

  • Facebook

    Join Healthcare Finance News on Facebook to connect with other readers!

Marketplace

  • Home
  • Issues
  • Resource Central
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • About Us
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
Healthcare Finance News is a publication of MedTech Publishing Company LLC.
For more information about MedTech Publishing Company and its publications, please visit medtechpublishing.com.
©2009 MedTech Publishing
Powered by Phase2 Technology.